Baseball | Men’s Hoops | Women’s Hoops | Men’s Bowling | Football | Men’s Golf | Women’s Golf | Gymnastics | Men’s Soccer | Women’s Soccer | Softball | Swimming | Men’s Tennis | Women’s Tennis | Track & Cross Country | Men’s Volleyball | Women’s Volleyball | Wrestling | Men’s Lacrosse | Women’s Lacrosse
| Baseball |
| Name | Year | College |
| Dallas Arthur | 2022 | Earlham College |
| Jacob Beall | 2021 | University of Akron |
| Grant Miller | 2021 | Ball State University |
| Carter Rust | 2021 | University of Charleston |
| Alex Jarboe | 2020 | Northwood University |
| Bradley Vargas | 2020 | Rockingham Community College |
| Michael Lorenz | 2020 | Waubonsee Community College |
| Nic Lenzer | 2020 | Centre College |
| Brandon Smith | 2019 | Wilmington College |
| Matt Brankamp | 2019 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Keegan Fish | 2018 | Ohio State University/Drafted by the Miami Marlins in the 13th round |
| Andrew Brownley | 2018 | Otterbein University |
| Michael Medley | 2018 | Earlham College |
| Aiden Reverman | 2018 | Thomas More University |
| Craig Nixon | 2018 | Muskingum University |
| Alex Dodson | 2017 | Ohio Northern Unversity |
| Josh Harrison | 2017 | Wake Technical CC |
| Eric Hooper | 2017 | Heidelberg University |
| Jacob Kates | 2017 | High Point University |
| Noah Maurer | 2017 | Cedarville University |
| Alssan Ramsby | 2017 | Toledo |
| Chase Wullenweber | 2017 | Tusculum College |
| Dominic Schivone | 2017 | Heildelberg University |
| Corey Peters | 2017 | Earlham |
| Brennen Martin | 2017 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Austin Allinger | 2015 | Evansville |
| Brandon Giltrow | 2015 | Wright State |
| Dallas Hall | 2015 | Miami University |
| Andrew Huser | 2015 | Seton Hill |
| Gloria Corona-Luna | 2015 | Morehead State University |
| Blaine Griffiths | 2014 | Xavier University |
| Drew Deaton | 2014 | Bellarmine |
| Grant Schuermann | 2014 | Furman University |
| Bryan Thurnauer | 2014 | Georgetown |
| Erik Hunkemoeller | 2013 | Capital University |
| Ryan Addington | 2013 | Carson Newman University |
| Ryan Ostendorf | 2013 | Wooster University |
| Malik Zuberi | 2012 | Shawnee State |
| Zak Farmer | 2012 | Walsh University |
| Davis Schafer | 2012 | Bellarmine University |
| Mike Seaman | 2012 | Trine University |
| Nick Billman | 2012 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Jake Wagner | 2012 | Miami-Hamilton |
| TJ Belieu | 2011 | Miami-Hamilton |
| Ben Flannery | 2010 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Mark Fowler | 2010 | Wabash Valley College/Wright State |
| Collin Shaw | 2010 | Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Jake May | 2010 | Coastal Carolina |
| Kyle Poole | 2010 | Malone University |
| Preston Thompson | 2010 | University of Northwestern Ohio |
| Bryan Beaver | 2009 | Miami University |
| Ricky Finley | 2009 | Sinclair State |
| Nate Smith | 2009 | Furman University |
| Tyler and Justin Vaske | 2008 | Denison College |
| Jimmy Brenneman | 2008 | Lincoln Trail Junior College/ Campbell University |
| Robert Shaw | 2008 | University of Northwestern Ohio |
| Brad Gschwind | 2007 | Miami Univ. |
| Brandon Reder | 2007 | Ohio State-Newark |
| Collin Taylor | 2007 | Eastern Michigan University |
| Dustin Huff | 2007 | Murray State |
| Dane Fienning | 2007 | University of Cincinnati |
| Bryan Post | 2007 | UC- Clermont |
| Mike Stidham | 2007 | UC- Clermont |
| Kyle Donawerth | 2006 | Miami University |
| Steve Mirizzi | 2006 | Lincoln Trail Junior College |
| Jarrad Chapman | 2005 | Urbana Univ. |
| Kyle Lucal | 2005 | Elmhurst College |
| Zach Hardesty | 2005 | Urbana Univ. |
| Josh Colliver | 2005 | Univ. of Toledo |
| Devin Mundey | 2005 | Miami-Hamilton |
| Ryan Shaw | 2004 | Morehead State Univ. |
| Steve Williams | 2004 | Wabash Valley Junior College |
| Kyle Chapman | 2003 | University of Cincinnati |
| Matt Klinker | 2003 | Furman University |
| Mike Schmidt | 2003 | Tiffin University |
| Paul Robbins | 2003 | Tiffin University |
| David Hartman | 2003 | Ohio Northern/Xavier |
| Mark Lallathin | 2003 | Miami University |
| Jon Oliver | 2002 | Wooster |
| Brad Stelzer | 2002 | Tiffin University |
| Scott Hicks | 2002 | Univ. of South Carolina Spartenburg |
| Ben Humphrey | 2002 | Olney J.C./Central Michigan Univ. |
| Brandon Beyerlein | 2001 | Marietta College |
| Bryan Davis | 2001 | Rend Lake J.C./Southern Indiana |
| Austin Rhoads | 2001 | Indiana Univ./Miami Univ. |
| Roddy Stieger | 2001 | Marshall University |
| Justin Mundt | 2000 | Mississippi Gulf Coast J.C./Northern Kentucky |
| Josh Romero | 2000 | Indiana Univ./ Univ. of Cincinnati |
| Andy Dunn | 2000 | Mt. Vernon College of the Nazarene |
| Chris Bonati | 1998 | College of Mt. Saint Joseph |
| Ryan Venturi | 1998 | Depauw University |
| Basketball Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Nate Dudukovich | 2023 | Thomas More University |
| Jaylen Jenkins | 2023 | Defiance College |
| Jason Lavender | 2023 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| William Layfield | 2021 | Bluffton University |
| Julian Mackey | 2020 | Niagara University |
| Carter Combs | 2020 | Capital University |
| Tyler Williams | 2014 | Brown University |
| Tyler Bowling | 2014 | Seton Hill |
| Monty Boykins | 2013 | Lafayette University |
| Ali Barnes | 2013 | Concord University/Miami University |
| Zach Moo Young | 2013 | Oberlin College |
| Jackson Blue | 2012 | Heidelberg University |
| Brandon Candella | 2009 | Wilmington College |
| Matt Karaffa | 2006 | Bowling Green |
| Josh Chichester | 2006 | Louisville (on a football scholarship but played in a few basketball games when the Cardinals were short-handed.) |
| Dale Smiley | 2002 | Poly Tech. University |
| Andy Dunn | 2000 | Mt.Vernon Nazarene College |
| Dan Hutzelman | 1999 | Findlay College |
| Matt Maxwell | 1998 | Wilmington College |
| Basketball Womens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Star Owens | 2023 | Hiram College |
| Emily Doerman | 2022 | Wittenberg University |
| Amara Flores | 2022 | Transylvania University |
| Liz Key | 2022 | Muskingum University |
| Beri Ngwa | 2022 | Miami University-Hamilton |
| Leah Aribat | 2021 | Miami University-Hamilton |
| Navaeh Dean | 2020 | Virginia Tech University |
| Jessica Clark | 2020 | Tiffin University |
| Sydney Benning | 2019 | Drury University |
| Jaydis Gales | 2019 | California University of Pennsylvania |
| Abby Prohaska | 2018 | University of Notre Dame |
| Sarah Jones | 2018 | Embry-Riddle University |
| Ally Haar | 2018 | Niagara University |
| Juliauna Howard | 2017 | Thomas More College |
| Angelia Jackson | 2017 | Otterbein University |
| Claire Myree | 2017 | Bluffton University |
| Nia Staples | 2016 | West Virginia University |
| Danielle Wells | 2016 | Indiana University East |
| Lexi Wasan | 2016 | Shawnee State |
| Lauren Cannatelli | 2015 | University of Dayton |
| Arianne Whitaker | 2015 | Winthrop/University of Chattanooga |
| Ellie Kivell | 2014 | Wilmington College |
| Rachel Huxhold | 2012 | College of Wooster |
| Adrianna McNeal | 2012 | Southwestern Illinois College |
| Rachel Mills | 2012 | Alderson Broddus College |
| Ali Zieverink | 2012 | Shawnee State |
| Ronni Grandison | 2011 | University of Massachusetts/NJIT Highlanders |
| Mea Williams | 2011 | Wilmington College/Mount St. Josephs |
| Kindsay Brandt | 2010 | Santa Fe College/Miami University, Oxford |
| Tessa Elkins | 2009 | Murray State University |
| Brittany Harriel | 2009 | Southeast Missouri State University |
| Meagan McCalla | 2009 | Capital University |
| Alexis Rogers | 2009 | Duke University/Bowling Green U. |
| Allison Whitenack | 2008 | University of the Cumberlands |
| Stephanie Whitenack | 2008 | Wingate University |
| Emma Zieverink | 2008 | Longwood University |
| Stacie Lee | 2008 | Jamestown Community College / U.C.-Clermont |
| Amber Gray | 2008 | University of Tennessee /Xavier U. |
| Quinessa Johnson | 2008 | St. Francis (Pa)/Nova Southeastern U. |
| Lauren Dugan | 2006 | Ohio Dominican College |
| Laura Hyden | 2005 | Ursuline College |
| Tricia Fuller | 2005 | Ohio Northern University |
| Molly Jendzio | 2005 | Thomas Moore College |
| Shana Fohl | 2003 | Cincinnati State |
| Stephanie Comisar | 2003 | Wright State University |
| Andrea Carlberg | 2002 | University of Indianapolis |
| Alicia Montgomery | 2002 | Mt.St Josephs College |
| Cara Wright | 2001 | University of Arkansas/University of Dayton |
| Danielle McClendon | 2000 | Sinclair Community College |
| Lisa Hutzelman | 2000 | Miami University at Middletown |
| Jessica Wiltshire | 1998 | Miami University at Middletown |
| Kelli Waggoner | 1998 | Ohio Northern University |
| Bowling Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| David Meadors | 2010 | Wright State |
| Football |
| Name | Year | College |
| Kofi Bobie | 2023 | Centre College |
| Mitch Bolden | 2023 | US Military Academy |
| Michael Brankamp | 2023 | Centre College |
| Sam Darla | 2023 | Otterbein University |
| Josh Fussell | 2023 | Northwestern University |
| Malik Hartford | 2023 | The Ohio State University |
| Scott Johnson | 2023 | Hanover College |
| Alex Key | 2023 | Marian University |
| Aaron Khayo | 2023 | Mount Saint Joseph University |
| Ben Minich | 2023 | University of Notre Dame |
| Alex Afari | 2022 | University of Kentucky |
| Jyaire Brown | 2022 | The Ohio State University |
| Cameron Goode | 2022 | Independence Community College |
| Bryan Henderson | 2022 | Indiana State University |
| Lathan McComis | 2022 | Wofford College |
| Aden Miller | 2022 | University of Charleston |
| Tegra Tshabola | 2022 | The Ohio State University |
| William Barber | 2021 | Robert Morris University |
| Cole Barela | 2021 | Taylor University |
| Ed Bolden | 2021 | Wittenberg University |
| Joshua Brogden | 2021 | Ohio University |
| Champ Gillespie | 2021 | University of Charleston |
| Matthew Howard | 2021 | Ohio Northern University |
| Kweisi Jones | 2021 | Thomas More University |
| Jackson Kuwatch | 2021 | The Ohio State University |
| Daniel Laritz | 2021 | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| Max Owsley | 2021 | Ashland University |
| Andre Proffitt | 2021 | University of Akron |
| Caleb Rao | 2021 | Valparaiso University |
| Kam Vargas | 2021 | West Virginia State University |
| Aneesh Vyas | 2021 | Bucknell University |
| Silas Walters | 2021 | Miami University (OH) |
| Daved Jones | 2020 | University of Cincinnati |
| David Afari | 2020 | Miami University (OH) |
| Isaac Kolosik | 2020 | Butler University |
| Jake Kieffer | 2020 | Morehead University |
| Steven Faucheux | 2019 | Purdue University |
| Dylan Jones | 2019 | Naval Academy |
| Ryan Francisco | 2019 | Marian University |
| LaDonnis Griffin | 2019 | Tiffin University |
| Nick Hjort | 2019 | Ohio Dominican |
| Terrance Owensby | 2019 | University of Bluffton |
| Jalen Swanson | 2019 | Morehead State University |
| Xavier Peters | 2018 | Florida State University |
| Tyler Bentley | 2018 | University of Pittsburgh |
| Cedric Thomas | 2018 | University of Pikeville |
| Christopher Johnson | 2018 | University of Findlay |
| Jordan Harris | 2018 | Wilmington College |
| Zelwyn Robinson | 2017 | Georgetown College |
| Brian Qua | 2017 | Grand Valley State University |
| David Walcott | 2017 | Ball State University |
| Tony White | 2017 | University of Pikeville |
| Will Nguyen | 2017 | Georgetown College |
| Payton Porterfield | 2017 | Hocking College |
| Tim Tanner-Blair | 2016 | Bowling Green State |
| Zach Nutter | 2016 | Baldwin Wallace |
| Jack Nguyen | 2016 | Georgetown College |
| Kavanaugh McCarthy | 2016 | Butler University |
| Sean Mahone | 2016 | West Virginia University |
| Luc Gendreau | 2016 | Centre College |
| George Asafo-Adjei | 2015 | University of Kentucky |
| CJ Stalker | 2015 | University of Virginia |
| Braxton Neal | 2015 | University of Cincinnati |
| Donte Horton | 2015 | Western Michigan University |
| Blake Darland | 2015 | Lake Erie College |
| Dante Jones | 2015 | Indiana State University |
| Troy Jones | 2015 | Marian University |
| Brady Bowling | 2015 | Gannon University |
| Nolan Ulizio | 2015 | University of Michigan |
| Butch Chaney | 2014 | Wittenberg |
| Jack Cleary | 2014 | Dennison University |
| Connor Radeck | 2014 | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Landon Johnson | 2014 | Franklin College |
| Jarin Higginbotham | 2014 | Moorehead |
| Jesus Long | 2014 | Thomas More College |
| Emmanuel Tshabola | 2014 | Thomas More College |
| Grant Patterson | 2014 | Mount St. Joe |
| Justin Martin | 2014 | Miami University |
| Tyler Jones | 2014 | Georgetown College |
| Mikel Horton | 2014 | University of Kentucky |
| Malik Grove | 2014 | Notre Dame College |
| Jawan Holmes | 2014 | Carson-Newman College |
| Paxston Robinson | 2014 | East Tennessee State |
| Trent Rogers | 2014 | University of Cincinnati |
| Michael Carter | 2013 | Heidelberg University |
| Daulton Frasier | 2013 | Miami University (Ohio) |
| Liam Maloney | 2013 | Morehead State |
| Ryan Martin | 2013 | Capital University |
| Luke Scott | 2013 | Capital University |
| Kyle Meadows | 2013 | University of Kentucky |
| Mike Kelly | 2013 | Naval Academy |
| Drew Garbenis | 2013 | Robert Morris |
| Ben Pendery | 2013 | Dayton University |
| Nick Bengal | 2013 | Gannon University |
| Blake Bell | 2012 | California PA |
| Jordan Darland | 2013 | Thomas More College |
| Dawson Fletcher | 2012 | Indiana University |
| Cole Stalker | 2012 | University of Findlay |
| Beau Odom | 2012 | Georgetown |
| Kayaune Ross | 2012 | Fort Scott Community College |
| Bubba Williams | 2012 | Lindsey Wilson |
| Dylan Romero | 2011 | Kentucky Christian University |
| Ben Gooch | 2011 | Centre College |
| Tyrez Shipmon | 2011 | Central State University |
| Cody Bowling | 2011 | Butler University |
| Matt Fox | 2011 | Ball State University |
| Phil Brinkman | 2011 | University of Indianapolis |
| Ryan Kelly | 2011 | University of Alabama |
| David Burke | 2010 | Butler University |
| Jordan Hicks | 2010 | University of Texas |
| Brandon Neal | 2010 | Youngstown State |
| Obi Nwankwo | 2010 | University Tennessee Martin |
| Connor Powell | 2010 | Hanover College |
| Alex Savage | 2010 | Centre College |
| Kevin Schloemer | 2010 | University of Cincinnati |
| Alex Smith | 2010 | University of Kentucky/ Georgia State |
| Jordan Thompson | 2010 | Youngstown State University |
| Zach Wimmers | 2009 | Denison University |
| Jared Charles | 2009 | Tiffin University |
| Stephen Houston | 2009 | Independence (Kan.) Community College/ Indiana University |
| Jake Odom | 2009 | Eastern Illinois University |
| Grant Poston | 2009 | Centre College |
| Ryan Turner | 2009 | Eastern Illinois University |
| Taylor Breen | 2008 | Truman State University |
| D.J. Brown | 2008 | Miami University |
| Bakari Bussey | 2008 | Ohio University |
| Matt Foor | 2008 | Butler University |
| Zach Leimberger | 2008 | Georgetown College |
| Gabe Patten | 2008 | Georgetown College |
| Andrew Phelan | 2008 | Miami University |
| Dwight Phillips | 2008 | California Univ. (PA) |
| Andrew Straus | 2008 | Elon University |
| Nate Toney | 2007 | University of Findlay |
| Grant Hunter | 2007 | Butler University |
| Robby Schloemer | 2007 | Georgetown College |
| Solomon Thomas | 2007 | The Ohio State University |
| Alex Kaufman | 2007 | Miami University |
| Andrew Cottrell | 2007 | Grand Valley State University |
| Devin Favors | 2007 | Grand Valley State University |
| Mike Linger | 2007 | Michigan State University |
| Corey Monroe | 2007 | Georgetown College |
| Tadd Dombart | 2007 | Butler University |
| Kyle Blevins | 2006 | Ohio Dominican (NAIA) |
| Paul Young | 2006 | Ohio Northern (D3) |
| Brent Black | 2006 | Bethel College (D3) |
| J.C. Casper | 2006 | Ohio Northern University (D3) |
| CC. Brooks | 2006 | St. Joes(IN) (D2) |
| Jeremy Coleman | 2006 | Central State (D2) |
| Kareem Riley | 2006 | Savannah State (D1-AA) |
| Eric Monroe | 2006 | Indiana State (D1-AA) |
| Josh Chichester | 2006 | University of Louisville (D1) |
| John Conner | 2005 | University of Kentucky |
| Steve Huff | 2005 | Murray State University |
| Jesse Brooks | 2005 | College of Mt. Saint Joes |
| Dane Romero | 2005 | Wofford College |
| Justin Chapman | 2004 | College of Wooster |
| Trey Iverson | 2004 | Georgetown College |
| Brandon Poston | 2004 | Georgetown College |
| Evan Spanogians | 2004 | University of South Carolina |
| Steve Rehring | 2004 | The Ohio State University |
| Matt Kruyer | 2003 | Wittenburg University |
| Brandon Maupin | 2003 | The Ohio State University |
| Dan Breech | 2002 | West Virginia Wesleyan |
| Mike Lovell | 2002 | College of Mt. St. Joe |
| Chris May | 2002 | Morehead State University |
| Mike Scrudato | 2002 | Hanover College |
| Adam Blanford | 2002 | Centre College |
| Brenton Eisenhard | 2002 | College of Mt. St. Joe |
| Tony Drew | 2002 | Muskingum College |
| Andrew Moore | 2002 | Avila College |
| David Pflasterer | 2002 | University of Tennessee at Martin |
| Chris Alles | 2002 | University of Tennessee at Martin |
| Mike Moffo | 2001 | Anderson University |
| Steve Norton | 2001 | University of Dayton |
| Aaron Mcqueen | 2001 | Urbana University |
| Aaron Keys | 2001 | Urbana University |
| David Hutzelman | 2001 | Miami University |
| Jason Leimberger | 2001 | Purdue University |
| Bobby Mullins | 2000 | Thomas More College |
| Aaron York | 2000 | Georgetown College |
| Nick Brown | 2000 | Gardner Webb University |
| Craig Spite | 2000 | Thomas More College |
| Ross Schnitzler | 2000 | Hanover College |
| Joe Spadafora | 2000 | Urbana University |
| Gerald Parker | 2000 | Georgetown College |
| Bob Mullins | 2000 | Thomas More College |
| Kofi Babb | 1999 | Wittenberg University |
| Dan Kaeppner | 1999 | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| Eric Benson | 1999 | Capital University |
| Mike Connor | 1999 | Capital University |
| Matt Lawless | 1999 | University of Findlay |
| Nathan Loucks | 1998 | Air Force Academy |
| Golf Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Jacob Brownley | 2019 | Ohio Dominican University |
| Marshall Stretch | 2013 | Ohio Dominican University |
| Jeffrey Wray | 2013 | Cincinnati State |
| Korey Ward | 2011 | Xavier |
| Sean Pramuk | 2002 | Urbana |
| Kenton Hobbs | 2001 | Xavier |
| Jason Hotaling | 1998 | New Mexico |
| Golf Womens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Ellie Myers | 2021 | Bryant University |
| Laura Russell | 2019 | Maryville College |
| Brooke Aragon | 2019 | Thomas More University |
| Abby Wagner | 2019 | Thomas More University |
| Ali Green | 2012 | Ashland |
| Taylor Wogenstahl | 2011 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Ashley Jeffers | 2011 | Western Illinois University |
| Kari Hogeback | 2010 | Eastern Michigan University |
| Lauren Ellerman | 2008 | University of Evansville |
| Rachel Nelson | 2008 | Western Carolina University |
| Marissa Steen | 2008 | University of Memphis |
| Jenny Linville | 2007 | University of Cincinnati |
| Lindsay Steiner | 2006 | Xavier Univ. |
| Ana Brown | 2002 | Ohio University |
| Stefanie Eifert | 1999 | University of Toledo |
| Alicia Brown | 1998 | University of Cincinnati |
| Gymnastics |
| Name | Year | College |
| Alina Miller | 2019 | Arizona State University |
| Kaci Martir | 2017 | Temple University |
| Brianna Brown | 2014 | University of Michigan |
| Ashley Priess | 2008 | University of Alabama |
| Courtney Priess | 2003 | University of Alabama |
| Soccer Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Jeremy Fuller | 2021 | Defiance College |
| Kyler Hagstrom | 2021 | Wittenberg University |
| Ashton Kamdem | 2021 | University of Akron |
| Cade Morgan | 2021 | Bellarmine University |
| Paul Walters | 2021 | Northwestern University |
| Hunter Little | 2020 | Transylvania University |
| Linden Eberle | 2018 | Capital University |
| Wesly Coleman | 2017 | Wright State University |
| Andrew Brengelman | 2017 | Malone University |
| Jeffrey Douyere | 2017 | Earlham College |
| Jeremy Douyere | 2017 | Earlham College |
| Brandon Whited | 2017 | Heidelberg University |
| Aaron Ledermeier | 2015 | Cincinnati State |
| Christian Lytle | 2015 | Case Western |
| Jake Mutlu | 2015 | Cincinnati State |
| Kyle Brotherton | 2014 | Capital University |
| Hunter Stiger | 2014 | Capital University |
| Hall Banks | 2014 | Cincinnati State |
| Gabe Welp | 2014 | Brown University |
| Joe McClanahan | 2013 | University of Findley |
| Josh Spaw | 2012 | Capital University |
| Robert Hasselfeld | 2011 | University of Cincinnati |
| Ian Hamilton | 2011 | Cumberland University |
| Nick Hagglund | 2010 | Xavier University |
| Derek Herzog | 2010 | Cincinnati Christian University |
| John Wittich | 2010 | Hanover College |
| Michael Proctor | 2009 | Bellarmine University |
| Robert Bowling | 2009 | Bellarmine University |
| Danny Elmore | 2008 | Cincinnati Christian University |
| Matt Bahner | 2008 | University of Cincinnati |
| Kyle Maxam | 2008 | Mr. Vernon Nazarene University |
| Anthony Montgomery | 2007 | Wilmington College |
| Adam Tenhundfeld | 2006 | Ohio State Univ |
| Jabel Parayil | 2005 | Transylvania University |
| Kyle Bertz | 2005 | Urbana Univ. |
| Ryan Kustos | 2004 | Ohio State Univ |
| Kevin NoSchang | 2004 | Indiana Univ. |
| John Mellencamp | 2004 | Indiana Univ. |
| Matt Fuller | 2002 | Dennison College (OH) |
| Kenney Bertz | 2002 | University of Maryland |
| Ian Mellencamp | 2001 | IUPUI (IN) |
| Kyle Winkler | 2000 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Andy Lallathin | 1999 | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Bryan Heard | 1999 | Wright State University |
| Brett Dunlap | 1999 | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Kyle Grady | 1998 | Earlham College (IN) |
| Mike Norton | 1998 | Centre College (KY) |
| Rajeev Darolia | 1998 | Washington University (St. Louis) |
| Billy Gronostaj | 1998 | Wilmington College |
| Josh Hutson | 1998 | Wright State University |
| Soccer Womens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Morgan Blanchet | 2023 | Thomas More University |
| Camryn Broz | 2023 | University of Cumberlands |
| Leah Fisher | 2023 | Ohio Dominican University |
| Isabella Gallo | 2022 | Walsh University |
| Hanna Mullholland | 2022 | University of the Cumberlands |
| Gabi Nelson | 2022 | Lawrence Tech University |
| Emily Pate | 2022 | Ashland University |
| Kylee Simmons | 2022 | University of Missouri |
| Sarah Watson | 2022 | Ashland University |
| Sydney Jones | 2021 | Ohio State University |
| Kailyn Dudukovich | 2021 | Ohio State University |
| Savannah Grubbs | 2021 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Julianne Hureau | 2021 | Kenyon College |
| Brooke Brockman | 2021 | Cleveland State University |
| Maddie Prohaska | 2021 | Auburn University |
| Jenna Sitarski | 2020 | Ohio Northern University |
| Gabbie Boehm | 2020 | Heidelberg University |
| Madison Snowden | 2020 | Valparaiso University |
| Regan Meyer | 2020 | Marshall University |
| Vanessa Menchofer | 2020 | Ashland University |
| Sophia Denison | 2019 | St. Louis University |
| Sarah Miller | 2019 | Anderson University (SC) |
| Brooke Neu | 2019 | Anderson University (IN) |
| Adrianna Brewer | 2018 | Lander University |
| Desiree Grubbs | 2018 | Miami University |
| Hannah Planck | 2018 | Anderson University |
| Samantha Hausser | 2018 | University of Dayton |
| Jennifer Douyere | 2017 | Earlham College |
| Devin Duhme | 2017 | Lander University |
| Caley Murphy | 2017 | Mount St. Joe |
| Katrina Brickley | 2017 | Cincinnati State |
| Megan Lentz | 2015 | Cincinnati State |
| Evie Stepaniak | 2015 | Cincinnati State |
| Jordan Wuest | 2015 | Thomas More College |
| Ally Wimmers | 2014 | Thomas More College |
| Lauren Heger | 2014 | Ohio University |
| Maggie Hare | 2013 | Xavier University |
| Elle Nguyen | 2013 | Northern Kentucky |
| Lauren Rose | 2013 | Thomas More |
| Kim Love | 2012 | Purdue |
| Kelly Mack | 2012 | Wright State |
| Lauren Pratt | 2012 | Ohio Dominican University |
| Ashea Bell | 2011 | Cincinnati State |
| Alex Azeez | 2011 | Purdue University |
| Devyn Ciotti | 2011 | University of Louisville |
| Megan Cravenor | 2011 | University of Cincinnati |
| Brittany Wilkerson | 2010 | Lee University |
| Marie Argo | 2009 | Valparaiso University |
| Christine Brewer | 2009 | University of Cincinnati |
| Maggie Brown | 2009 | Ball State University |
| Cassie Lingenhoel | 2009 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Brigit Reder | 2009 | Ball State University |
| Tiffany Weinheimer | 2009 | Ball State University |
| Alexis Dickison | 2008 | Indiana University |
| Caitlin Dombart | 2008 | University of Illinois |
| Kelsie Dreisbach | 2008 | Coastal Carolina |
| Kristin Tenhundfeld | 2007 | Transylvania |
| Morgan Price | 2007 | Northern Kentucky |
| Victoria Bachand | 2007 | University of Iowa |
| Amy Lower | 2006 | Ohio University |
| Abby Mink | 2006 | Wright State University |
| Cara Nielsen | 2006 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| Katy Rudokas | 2006 | Xavier University |
| Kaley Connelly | 2005 | Marquette University |
| Brianne Eisenhard | 2005 | Bowling Green University |
| Rachel Ulrich | 2005 | University of Kentucky |
| Alex Casper | 2004 | Grand Valley State University |
| Kara Gostisha | 2004 | University of Illinois |
| Lindsay Martin | 2004 | Ball State |
| Kristen Miller | 2004 | Ohio University |
| Jenny Ng | 2004 | University of Akron |
| Lindsey Price | 2004 | Ohio University |
| Brooke Rockwern | 2004 | Kenyon College |
| Carlin Scrudato | 2004 | Thomas More College |
| Katie Comisar | 2003 | Wright State University |
| Stephanie Comisar | 2003 | Wright State University |
| Meghan Connelly | 2003 | Marquette University |
| Lauren Podvin | 2003 | George Mason/ Louisville |
| Marianne Schilling | 2003 | Butler University |
| Ashley Hadley | 2002 | Northwestern State University |
| Katie Ng | 2002 | Miami University |
| Leigh Carroll | 2001 | University of Louisville |
| Kim Comisar | 2001 | Purdue University |
| Krista Kalkhoff | 2001 | Wilmington College |
| Gina Lower | 2001 | University of Louisville |
| Amy Miller | 2001 | Valparaiso University |
| Shawn Reynolds | 2001 | Arizona State |
| Clare Applegate | 2000 | Wilmington College |
| Courtney Budd | 2000 | Valparaiso University |
| Kara McCue | 2000 | University of Kentucky |
| Amy Mink | 2000 | U. of Massachusetts/Cincinnati |
| Rachel Podvin | 2000 | Capital University |
| Amber Wilson | 2000 | U. of Michigan/Kentucky |
| Shannon Myers | 1999 | St. Louis University |
| Heather Peppers | 1999 | Wright State University |
| Laren Kriner | 1998 | University of Iowa |
| Softball |
| Name | Year | College |
| Leilah Ferrari | 2023 | Denison University |
| Tionna Bright | 2023 | Notre Dame College |
| Kendall Forren | 2021 | Miami University (Ohio) |
| Molly Grace | 2021 | University of Dayton |
| Belle Hummel | 2021 | Ohio University |
| KK Mathis | 2021 | James Madison University |
| Cameron Wesley | 2019 | Wright State |
| Remmington Steckler | 2019 | Martin Methodist |
| Jenna Harris | 2019 | Lourdes University |
| Alyssa Triner | 2019 | Trevecca Nazarene University |
| Casey Bramble | 2019 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Alyssa Witmer | 2019 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Allie Cummins | 2018 | Miami University |
| Megan Brankamp | 2017 | Georgetown College |
| Taylor Bramlett | 2017 | Cincinnati Christian Universtiy |
| Megan Edwards | 2017 | Transtlvania University |
| Marisa Brown | 2015 | University of Indianapolis |
| Ciara Incorvati | 2015 | Bellarmine |
| Haley Johnson | 2015 | Thomas More |
| Madeline Kurtz | 2015 | Bellarmine |
| Kat Burbrink | 2014 | Trevecca Nazarene |
| Emily Dozier | 2014 | Cedarville University |
| Alyssa Hedric | 2014 | Miami University |
| Ashley Sharp | 2014 | Wright State University |
| Amanda Lahti | 2012 | Ohio Northern |
| Alex Caudill | 2011 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Yasmin Battle | 2011 | Mississippi Valley State University |
| Rachael Shepherd | 2007 | Ohio State Univ. |
| Leah Ledford | 2006 | Ohio State Univ |
| Lindsay Bodeker | 2006 | Akron Univ./Ohio State Univ. |
| Rachel Denham | 2006 | Ohio University |
| Keir McEachern | 2004 | Kent State Univ |
| Swimming |
| Name | Year | College |
| Sara Glosson | 2023 | University of Toledo |
| Ashley Fryer | 2021 | Bowling Green State University |
| Morgan Allison | 2021 | Valparaiso University |
| Grace Glosson | 2020 | University at Buffalo |
| Griffin Manning | 2018 | University of Louisville |
| McKenzie Rice | 2018 | University of Akron |
| Kelsey Rebman | 2017 | Wright State University |
| Erica Morris | 2017 | Saint Louis University |
| Casey Frazier | 2014 | Miami University |
| Bryan McNamara | 2013 | Miami University |
| John Raker | 2013 | Ohio Northern University |
| Rikkie Shumard | 2013 | Urbana University |
| Brooke Rowley | 2012 | Lake Forest College |
| Michael Hart | 2010 | Georgia Tech |
| Maegen Krugler | 2010 | University of Toledo |
| Brendan McNamara | 2010 | University of Kentucky |
| Katy Hare | 2008 | Duquesne University |
| Chewy Vogule | 2007 | Ashland University |
| Katie Severson | 2000 | Ohio State University |
| Kelley O’Hara | 1999 | Bowling Green State University |
| Kyle O’Hara | 1998 | Bowling Green State University |
| Tennis Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Anthony Shalakov | 2023 | US Military Academy |
| Nicholas Lang | 2013 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Wyatt Lippert | 2009 | Ohio State University |
| Taylor Broda | 2008 | University of Indianapolis |
| Tennis Womens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Florine Sanchez | 2019 | Ohio Northern University |
| Sharon Danqua | 2015 | University of Illinois-Springfield |
| Brooke Broda | 2014 | Notre Dame |
| Nicole Soutar | 2013 | Northern Kentucky |
| Ashleigh Witte | 2010 | University of Cincinnati |
| Robin Burnette | 2007 | Capital University |
| Aleia Brown | 2006 | Copping State Univ |
| Jennifer Kelly | 2005 | Robert Morris / Univ. of Cincinnati |
| Track and Field / Cross Country |
| Name | Year | College |
| Haley Troy | 2023 | Wittenberg University |
| Lauren Mang | 2023 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Nicholas Costas | 2023 | Tiffin University |
| Jack Ferguson | 2023 | Wittenberg University |
| Max Martindale | 2023 | Wittenberg University |
| Brayden Rice | 2023 | Ashland University |
| Kylie Dilley | 2022 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Zach Beneteau | 2021 | Walsh University |
| Coleman Cronk | 2021 | Florida State University |
| Annika Kinley | 2021 | University of Cincinnati |
| Michael Lane | 2021 | Ohio University |
| Kaleb Martin | 2021 | Ohio State University |
| Sergio Negroe | 2021 | Ohio State University |
| Zach Plotkin | 2021 | Ohio State University |
| Julian Wagner | 2020 | Miami University (OH) |
| Malcolm Rencher | 2020 | Huntington University |
| Alex Kelker | 2019 | University of Toledo |
| Noah Mang | 2018 | Notre Dame College |
| Ben Dangel | 2018 | University of Cincinnati |
| Emma Cunningham | 2018 | Ball State University |
| Bekah Robertson | 2017 | Wright State University |
| Jules Howard | 2017 | Thomas More College |
| Logan Curington | 2017 | Northern Kentucky |
| Meridith Elstun | 2017 | Ohio University |
| Meg Schinner | 2017 | Otterbein University |
| Maya Andrews | 2015 | Morehead State |
| Simone Henderson | 2015 | Hanover College |
| Lara Aull | 2015 | Wright State University |
| Josh Oeters | 2015 | University of Toledo |
| Mykel Chambers | 2015 | University of Cincinnati |
| Laura Aull | 2015 | Wright State University |
| Sydney Hill | 2015 | University of Louisville |
| Will Wilson | 2013 | Ohio Northern University |
| Nathan Haynes | 2012 | Naval Academy |
| Brady Holmer | 2012 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Amanda Shelby | 2012 | Mount St. Joe |
| J.J. Webber | 2011 | Northern Kentucky University |
| Jordan Parayil | 2008 | Bellarmine University |
| Heath Gibson | 2007 | Otterbein College |
| Amanda Burger | 2007 | North Carolina State |
| Katie Ostendorf | 2006 | Otterbein |
| Taylor Candella | 2005 | Ohio State University |
| Kelly Bloemer | 2002 | Wright State University |
| Volleyball Mens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Dylan Kembre | 2010 | Lees McRea |
| Volleyball Womens |
| Name | Year | College |
| Kaiya Markley | 2022 | Tiffin University |
| Syd Hilderbran | 2021 | Thomas More |
| Sophia Schivone | 2018 | Lake Erie College |
| Megan Kaufman | 2017 | UT-Chattanooga |
| Haley Bergheger | 2017 | Georgetown College |
| Maya Krause | 2017 | Xavier University |
| Courtney Whited | 2017 | Tusculum College |
| Lexi Duello | 2015 | Central Michigan |
| Kelsey Boyle | 2015 | Slippery Rock |
| Bailey Nixon | 2015 | Alderson Broaddus |
| Gabby Blados | 2014 | Clemson University |
| Allie Muha | 2014 | Bellarmine |
| Annie Bierman | 2013 | Furman University |
| Mandy Stanislovaitis | 2013 | Adelphi University |
| Mel Stewart | 2012 | NKU |
| Corri Muha | 2012 | Georgetown College |
| Lexi Dannemiller | 2011 | University of Michigan |
| Liz McMahon | 2011 | University of Illinois |
| Kelley Calvi | 2008 | Newman University (KA) |
| Katelyn Crevenor | 2008 | Thomas More |
| Denay Detherage | 2007 | University of Cincinnati-Clermont |
| Kelli Clear | 2007 | UNC-Wilmington |
| Jenna Hagglund | 2007 | U. of Washington |
| Meagan Dooley | 2006 | University of Pittsburgh |
| Ali Zimmerman | 2005 | University of Findlay |
| Lauren Biel | 2005 | University of Cincinnati-Clermont |
| Ericka Duckworth | 2004 | University of Evansville |
| Laura Tyburski | 2003 | Tennessee Tech University |
| Lindsay Simpson | 2002 | Miami University |
| Kristin Russo | 1998 | LaSalle University |
| Wrestling |
| Name | Year | College |
| Cooper Skelton | 2023 | Ohio University |
| Joey Bradberry | 2018 | Otterbein University |
| Nick Bloch | 2012 | Lake Erie College |
| Ty Davis | 2011 | Central Michigan University/Ashland University |
| Ryan Fields | 2008 | UNC-Greensboro |
| Rick Weatherholt | 2007 | Heidelberg |
| Bo Touris | 2007 | Ohio State |
| Tony Bradberry | 2006 | Ashland Univ |
| Brian Almer | 2005 | Univ. of Indianapolis |
| Andrew Monk | 2004 | Ohio Univ |
| Zach Flake | 2003 | Campbellsville |
| Max Dean | 2003 | Indiana Univ/ Oklahoma University |
| Tony Drew | 2002 | Muskingum Univ. |
| Stephen Wolery | 2002 | Ohio State Univ. |
| Matt McIntire | 2002 | Indiana Univ |
| Chris Bonati | 1998 | Mt. St. Joes |
| Men’s Lacrosse |
| Name | Year | College |
| Carter Barrett | 2023 | University of the Cumberlands |
| John Blanton | 2021 | University of the Cumberlands |
| Robert Guise | 2021 | Capital University |
| J.D. Hale | 2021 | Ohio Northern University |
| Iason O’Neal | 2021 | Lincoln Memorial University |
| Logan Pecora | 2021 | Otterbein University |
| Brydan Pitman | 2021 | Ohio Northern University |
| Anderson Simpson | 2021 | Thomas More University |
| Colin Willits | 2021 | Ohio Northern University |
| Aiden Manning | 2019 | Capital University |
| Dylan Wiesman | 2018 | Capital University |
| Cameron Wehby | 2018 | Capital University |
| Gage Hafl | 2015 | Hanover College |
| Alex Cook | 2015 | Huntington College |
| Brennan O’Callaghan | 2014 | Capital University |
| Women’s Lacrosse |
| Name | Year | College |
| Anna Wells | 2023 | Thomas More University |
| Riley Hopkins | 2022 | Ohio Northern University |
| Lydia Lehman | 2022 | Ohio Northern University |
| Kennedy Manning | 2021 | Coastal Carolina |
| Faith Smiddy | 2020 | Thomas More University |
| Camille Johnston | 2018 | University of Cincinnati |
| Olivia Hocker | 2018 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Bella Halfhill | 2017 | Wofford College |
| Bella Halfhill | 2017 | Mount St. Joseph University |
| Abby Antelo | 2015 | University of Indianapolis |
| Rachel Kidwell | 2015 | Georgetown College |
| Taylor Mitchell | 2015 | Georgetown College |
| Kaylin Sabo | 2015 | Findlay |
| Danielle Acuna | 2014 | Walsh University |
| Amanda Hodel | 2014 | Walsh University |
